Why Raising Upstanders Gets an A+ Teaching kids to be bystanders and stay silent when they see things are wrong is not productive. BY SUSAN RAISCH
To empower our children we should teach them to stand-up to wrong-doing, not discourage them from tattling.
“ According to the students, the No. 1 most helpful adult action was listened to me.”
Schools are where children gain knowledge but itís also the place where they create connection and develop as social beings. Hopefully, itís a place where they feel they belong.
According to The School Climate Challenge, from the National School Climate Center, "School climate promotesóor complicatesóa studentís ability to learn and achieve academically. This is common sense. To the extent that students feel safe, cared for, appropriately supported and lovingly 'pushed' to learn, academic achievement should increase.
So what actions by adults positively impact studentsí sense of feeling valued? Part of the answer is as simple as giving children eye contact, knowing and using their names and engaging them in positive conversation. In other words, helping them be seen.
In an ideal world, they will always feel respected, but as millions of kids know, peer mistreatment happens. In those cases, itís the job of parents and school staff to make sure they are not only seen but also heard.
The Youth Voice Project researchers went to the source and surveyed over 13,000 students in grades 5-12 to assess what advice and actions actually help; which ones donít; and how do kids effectively help each other.
According to the students, the No. 1 most helpful adult action was listened to me.Listening, following up and giving advice ranked at the top and told me to stop tattling was at the bottom. Discouraging kids to report hurtful behavior is perhaps one of the worst things adults can do. If they donít tell, they canít receive help. Teaching them from young ages how to report something responsibly versus getting someone in trouble is a critical skill.
Kids need adult help but they also need each other. How do we mentor our children when theyíre the bystander witnessing mean behavior? Turn the role from a bystander to an upstander.
The difference between the two is action. Although itís good to ask kids to take action, training them to "confront" the child acting like a bully may not be the way to go. According to the Youth Voice Project, itís not the most effective and in some instances, makes the problem worse. Instead, kids report that the following list of peer actions are much more helpful:
Most Helpful Actions Overall
* Walked or spent time with me at school * Talked to me at school to encourage me * Gave me advice (hope) * Helped me get away; made a distraction * Helped me tell adults
Children can be taught how to "Step Up" to help another child out through empathy, inclusion, even humor and seeking help from trusted adults. By encouraging kids to communicate and then being present for them, the problem may not be immediately solved but the sense of safety will most likely remain intact.